Los Angeles Man Receives 52-Year Sentence for Mistaken Identity Murder

Share on:

Image Credit: none

In a harrowing case of mistaken identity, Marcos Medina, a 24-year-old man from Los Angeles, has been handed a severe sentence of 52 years to life in state prison for the tragic incident that occurred in Gardena. Judge Laura C. Ellison labeled the killing of 17-year-old David Amaro-Poblano as cold-blooded during the proceedings held at Torrance Superior Court.

Amaro-Poblano, an honor-roll student and avid soccer player, was merely months away from graduating from Environmental Charter High School in Lawndale when his life was abruptly cut short in February 2019. Accompanied by his mother and girlfriend, he was innocently standing on a sidewalk outside his aunt’s house while his mother distributed birthday party invitations for his younger sister. Little did they know that this routine task would become their worst nightmare.

Medina, along with an unidentified second suspect, approached the street in a vehicle. Without any provocation or justification, Medina swiftly exited the car, advanced three steps, and ruthlessly fired nine shots at Amaro-Poblano, who was struck once in the back. Despite his valiant attempt to reach the safety of his mother’s car, the young teenager collapsed and tragically succumbed to his injuries at a nearby hospital.

Amaro-Poblano’s grieving mother, Idalia Poblano-Reyes, shared her heart-wrenching testimony, emphasizing the immense pain and loss her family has endured since the senseless act. She expressed her deep love for her late son and highlighted his innocence, stating that he never sought trouble and had dreams of attending Cal State University, Dominguez Hills.

While Medina’s defense attorney, Daniel Melnick, pleaded for leniency, asserting Medina’s familial ties, Judge Ellison firmly rejected this argument. She believed that Medina had chosen his gang-affiliated relatives over his own family, branding the shooting as a callous act committed for the glory of his gang. Highlighting Medina’s lack of remorse and prior weapons-related convictions, as well as his parole status at the time of the crime, Ellison deemed it necessary to ensure public safety by imposing a substantial sentence.

As he was escorted out of the courtroom, Medina directed a loving message to his family, seemingly unaffected by the gravity of his actions. The convicted murderer had opted against making a statement during the hearing.

Prosecutors painted a picture of Medina and his accomplice purposefully seeking out a rival gang member to execute, only to mistakenly target Amaro-Poblano, an innocent young man with no gang affiliations. While Melnick argued against the credibility of the lone eyewitness who provided a description inconsistent with Medina’s appearance, prosecutors had a compelling jailhouse recording where Medina could be heard boasting about the shooting to a cellmate.

The tragedy took an even more disturbing turn when Medina chose to commemorate the killing by getting a tattoo on the left side of his left eye, later flaunting it on social media. Such brazen behavior further solidified the sentiments in the courtroom that he deserved no mercy.

In a poignant and powerful statement, Poblano-Reyes firmly stated that Medina did not deserve to be released from jail, and her son did not deserve the fate that befell him.

This devastating case serves as a grim reminder of the consequences of mistaken identity and the devastating impact of gang violence on innocent lives. As the community mourns the loss of a promising young individual, it is crucial to evaluate and address the root causes that perpetuate such senseless crimes.

Ryan Scott
Author: Ryan Scott

Just a guy

Share on: