Categories: CrimeDoor Originals

The Mysterious Death of Stephen Smith: Unraveling a South Carolina Tragedy Linked to the Murdaugh Family

Stephen Smith was a 19-year-old nursing student at Orangeburg–Calhoun Technical College whose death has drawn significant attention due to potential connections with the Murdaugh family, a prominent legal family in South Carolina.

Background on Stephen Smith:

  • Death: Stephen Smith was found dead from blunt force trauma on a rural road in Hampton County, near the Murdaugh family’s Moselle estate, on July 8, 2015. Initially, his death was ruled a hit-and-run accident.
  • Personal Details: Smith was openly gay and known to be a high school classmate of Buster Murdaugh, Alex Murdaugh’s eldest son.

Investigation and Speculations:

  • Initial Investigation: The case went cold with no arrests made, despite early investigations and interviews.
  • Allegations and Rumors: There were rumors and allegations in the Hampton County area regarding a potential cover-up and the possible involvement of members of the Murdaugh family in Smith’s death. Witnesses during the initial investigation had mentioned Buster Murdaugh’s potential involvement in a relationship with Smith, but no conclusive evidence was provided at the time.

Case Reopening:

  • Reopening of the Case: In June 2021, the South Carolina Law Enforcement Division (SLED) reopened the investigation into Stephen Smith’s death. This decision was based on unspecified evidence found during the investigation into the murders of Maggie and Paul Murdaugh, which occurred in June 2021.
  • Change in Case Classification: On March 22, 2023, SLED announced that they now classified Smith’s death as a murder rather than a hit-and-run accident.

Current Status:

  • No Charges or Indictments (as of December 2023): As of the latest information available to me, there have been no charges or indictments issued in relation to Stephen Smith’s death. The investigation remains ongoing.
  • Denial of Involvement: Buster Murdaugh, through a statement to the press, denied any involvement with Stephen Smith and his death, calling the rumors about his involvement “baseless.”


The case of Stephen Smith remains a complex and unresolved matter, with renewed interest due to its potential connections to the Murdaugh family. The reopening of the case and its reclassification as a murder investigation suggest that new evidence or insights have emerged, though specific details and the implications for the Murdaugh family remain unclear.

Author: Chris Morris

Chris Morris

Published by
Chris Morris

Recent Posts

Orthodox Jewish Man Brutally Stabbed in Rockland County Driveway

An Orthodox Jewish man was subjected to a brutal stabbing in his own driveway in…

4 hours ago

A&E Docuseries Explores Secrets of the Hells Angels, Unveiling Dark Underbelly of the Outlaw Biker Gang

A new A&E docuseries, "Secrets of the Hells Angels," delves into the hidden world of…

4 hours ago

Two Injured in Overnight Shootings Across Denver

Two people were injured in separate shootings that occurred overnight in Denver. The first incident…

4 hours ago

Majority of Voters Believe Trump Committed Serious Federal Crimes, Poll Shows

On the eve of jury selection in New York, a new poll reveals that a…

4 hours ago

Man Arrested After Firing Gunshots from Marina del Rey Apartment Building

A man was apprehended on Saturday night after allegedly firing multiple rounds of gunfire from…

4 hours ago

11 Shot, 1 Killed in Gang-Related Violence at Family Gathering on Chicago’s South Side

Chicago was struck by yet another wave of violence on Saturday night when a family…

4 hours ago